Where to Eat Pizza in Bellingham
In crust, we trust! 🍕 There are times you just want to sink your jaws into a hefty slice of pizza and lucky for you Bellingham is full of great pizza options including gluten-free and vegan pizza! We ❤️ pizza!
If you're looking for authentic Italian pizza made with fresh local ingredients, make a beeline for Storia Cucina in downtown Bellingham. Storia sources many of their ingredients from local farmers and fishers to create the freshest food possible.
Owner Jonathan Sutton is especially proud of his sourdough, which dates back to 1971 in San Francisco and has been kept alive ever since. The yeast-free dough, made a day ahead so it can rise slowly, makes a fantastic thin-crust pizza.
If there's a wait to get a seat (which can happen, this place is popular!), head to neighboring Bar Cicotti for a glass of wine or cocktail while you wait.
For anyone interested in a scenic drive and views with their meal, head up the Mount Baker Scenic Highway to The North Fork Brewery & Pizza.
Their hand-tossed crusts are made daily with specialty flour, olive oil, and beer...and gluten-free crusts are available, too! The house marinara is prepared fresh and there's an option for vegan cheese.
One thing you can always agree on for dinner is pizza – meat lovers, vegetarian, omnivore. But being vegan or having other reasons not to eat cheese makes pizza a little less adaptable. Luckily, Fiamma Pizza offers a plant-based cheese substitute as well as a gluten-free crust option. Just want a slice? Try La Fiamma's walk-up window, Pye Hole.
Sliced is locally owned and passionate about hospitality and food, with a constantly evolving menu featuring ingredients from local family farms, vineyards, and fisheries. They also make their own fresh pastas, breads, desserts, and more!
On top of all this, they have an extensive wine and spirits list along with the best craft cocktails in town. Their space can accommodate 120 people for private events, and they cater out for all occasions.
Sliced is located next to Bellis Fair Mall in Bellingham.
You know the feeling you get after a long workday, when you come home, put on some flannels, and pour yourself a beer? It’s called “completely relaxed,” which is how you’ll feel when you walk through the door at McKay’s Taphouse and Pizzeria. Pair it with a local Bellingham brew for a perfect pizza experience. McKay's is also known for its trivia nights.
More Pizza Spots
Bellinghamsters were thrilled when Zeeks opened a locally owned franchise in Bellingham's Fountain District. The menu boasts a variety of Pacific Northwest pizzas (known for fresh ingredients and a slightly chewy crust) and one of the largest tap lists in town. The roomy building makes it a great place for parties, sports-watching, and family outings.
They also operate a second location at The Portal Container Village on the Bellingham Waterfront!
Piping hot pan pizzas, humungous Hawaiian bread sandwiches, and cheese balls (also made with sweet Hawaiian bread), can all be yours at Coconut Kenny's. This tropical-themed pizza spot in Bellingham delivers creative, Hawaiian-inspired pizzas and a nice selection of salads for those wanting lighter fare. They also offer a gluten-free crust.
Aslan Depot
Aslan Depot in Downtown Bellingham now serves New York–inspired pizza. Drop by the cozy bar for a quick late-night bite or order a whole pie to share with friends. Anticipate pizza like you'd find in the big city - crispy outside, soft and chewy in the center.
Övn Wood Fired Pizza
Matt Brawner’s wood-fired oven from Naples, Italy had to be forklifted into the Neapolitan-inspired pizzeria in Bellingham’s Fairhaven district. The restaurant opened in August 2015 and Brawner and his pizza team have elevated pizza-making into an art form. “I’m a serious pizza maker,” Brawner said. “We’re also the only ones doing this particular kind of pizza.”
What is Neapolitan-style pizza, you ask? It’s simple pizza full of flavor, innovative toppings and hearty ingredients. Mozzarella curd is brought in from Wisconsin and flour is shipped all the way from Naples. And the tomato sauce? “We use whole crushed tomatoes instead of sauce – but most of our pizzas have a non-tomato base.”
In the kitchen, Brawner is all about attention-to-detail. “Everything we’re dealing with is living, organic processes. For example, we keep a yeast culture alive for our natural unleavened dough, and we’re making it nine to ten hours a day. We get the potential for really good texture and flavor from this dough.”
Check Ovn's website to find out about their all-you-can-eat pizza nights.
Tam Tam makes incredible pizza featuring ingredients sourced from the West Coast! The best part - you can find their pizza at multiple locations across Bellingham and Whatcom County, including the Downtown Bellingham Farmers Market, Lost Giants Cider Company, Fringe Brewering, Dockside Market, and the red bus in Fairhaven Village.
Another great destination for dairy-free pizza in Bellingham is Mod Pizza. Mod’s build-your-own model is ultimately customizable. They also offer plant-based Italian sausage, gluten-friendly crust, and cauliflower crust.
In addition to more than 1,000 carefully selected bottles of beer, cider, and more, this bottle shop in Bellingham's Lettered Streets neighborhood offers a menu of delicious 11-inch Neapolitan-style pizzas with high-quality toppings. It's some of the best pizza in Bellingham.
Located off Mount Baker Highway just outside of Bellingham, the Rome Bakery & Market - also called the Rome Store - offers an eclectic mix of groceries, espresso drinks, baked goods, to-go sandwiches and salads, beer on tap, and, of course, delicious hot pizza! Their artisan pizzas are handmade and feature local ingredients. Pick one up on your way to or from a trip to the Nooksack River or Mt. Baker.
